Design Systems September 26, 2023
Design composition rules every designer should know, and when to break them
When you look at a screen, you don't start with the words. Before you read a single label, you have already seen a shape and a colour.
I wrote about this on Instagram back in 2021, and I asked the question that still interests me: which one does the brain take in first, the shape or the colour? I looked for an answer and I didn't find proof either way. What I believe, from my own work, is that it depends on what you need. When you need meaning or utility, shape leads. When you need a feeling or have to make a judgment, colour leads.
Look at a paragraph of text from across the room. You see that it's grey, or dark, before you can make out one letter. Now picture a big car coming straight at you. You see the shape long before you know its colour.
So for me, composition means choosing what leads in each part of a screen, on purpose. Don Norman calls designers "the bridge between technology and the people, and human capabilities". The order we see things in is one of those capabilities.
In 2023 I wrote this article as five simple steps. The five foundations are still here. What changed is how I use them: each one is a decision a design system can make once, so no screen has to make it again.
1. Grid and spacing
Users never see your grid, but they feel it when it's missing. Without one, a layout feels cluttered and people lose their way through the page. A grid is columns, gutters and margins, with every gap built from one base unit.
Most teams use 8px as that base unit, because most screen sizes divide by 8, and 8 halves cleanly into 4 and 2. From it you get a short scale, 8, 16, 24, 32, and every width, height and gap is one step on it. Small details inside a component, like the space between an icon and its label, can use 4.
In 2023 I said you can break the grid to make something stand out, as long as it has a purpose. I still believe that. But you can only break a grid that exists. If every screen invents its own spacing, nothing stands out. Everything just looks slightly off.
In the design system I built for Fundara, spacing is a short list of named sizes, like --space-l. Nobody picks a number for a single screen anymore. They pick a size from the scale, and a developer who reads --space-l in the code knows what it means without opening Figma.
The scale is also a limit. Sometimes a designer wants a value it doesn't have, like a 6px gap in a dense data table, where 8px feels too loose and 4px feels cramped. I decide by asking how often the value is needed. If it's needed once, pick the closest size. If every table needs it, put the 6px inside the table component, so it's decided there and nobody types it by hand. If every team needs it, add a new step to the scale for everyone. Each answer keeps the decision in one place, and that's the reason the scale exists.
2. Type
Type sets the hierarchy. A reader should know what matters most before reading anything. You build that order with three things: size, weight and colour. A title is bigger, a label is bolder, a hint is lighter. If two of them say "important" in different places, the reader has to decide, and that is the moment the hierarchy breaks.
My clearest type rule comes from my finance product work: right-align money. When amounts line up on the right edge, the digits line up too, tens under tens and hundreds under hundreds, so you can compare a whole column at a glance. Left-aligned amounts make you read every number. It works best with tabular figures, a font setting that gives every digit the same width, so a 1 takes as much space as an 8. The rule is now one of the ten rules in the Claude pack that ships with Tessera, so an AI assistant building a screen follows it as well.
In 2023 I told beginners to avoid serif typefaces. I don't treat that as a rule anymore. Screens are sharp now, and whether a serif works depends on the brand and the size. A serif in a dense table at body size is a different question from a serif in a big headline. The type scale, and how numbers align, get decided once.
3. Colour
I'll keep this one short, because I've written about colour a lot. For the longer version, read How to Choose Your Color Palette Using Color Wheel, then the 60-30-10 rule, then Your Brand Color Isn't One Color.
Two things matter for composition. First, a colour changes with what's around it. This is simultaneous contrast: the same grey looks lighter on a dark ground and darker on a light one. You never see a colour alone, so you can't choose it alone.
Second, colour is where I learned to stop trusting my eyes. A chart palette in my earlier system measured 2.5:1 against white. It looked fine to me, and it was far too low for people to tell the lines apart. I replaced it. Since then no colour pair is finished until I've computed its ratio: 4.5:1 for text and 3:1 for graphics that carry meaning, in light mode and in dark. The system decides which pairs pass, and a check fails when someone uses one that doesn't.
4. Imagery and icons
In 2023 I wrote that icons need labels. Today I'd say it more strongly.
There are two kinds of icons. Actionable icons do something when you tap them: open, close, go somewhere. Informational icons only describe: a warning sign, a status. The shape has to tell you which kind you are looking at. An icon is a shape, and shape comes first, so when the shape promises something it can't do, the screen misleads you before you read a word.
I saw this when I reviewed Interdiscount's product comparison. Some icons looked like controls but did nothing. Tap one and nothing happens, and you wonder if you did something wrong. In the same review, promotional content filled the first view and pushed the products down. The loudest shapes on the page were not the ones people came for.
Then there's Klapp, the school app I use every day as a father of two. When I reviewed it, the icons and visual elements were hard to interpret, and a badge marked "Next" didn't tell you what would happen next. My recommendation was to add text that says what it does. In other words, a better label.
Labels cost space, and I think they're worth it. The "Next" badge also shows that a label has to say something: one vague word is not enough. A system decides this once: one icon set, one style, and whether an icon may stand without a label. My default is no.
5. Components
A while ago I sat in a meeting with a company in Zurich. Their product runs on desktop, tablet and phone, and I told them, as politely as I could, that it looked like two products, because their design system was weak, or they didn't have one. I didn't get the project. A year later a friend who works there told me they had hired someone to fix their design system.
I still think about that meeting. Nobody in that room had designed a bad button. The problem sat where nobody was looking. The menu was built twice, once by the web team and once by the app team. The items were in a different order, with different icons and different names for the same page. Users had to learn the product twice.
Take a simple user menu: every colour, space and line in it is a decision. When those decisions live in one place, the menu looks the same everywhere. When they live in people's heads, you get two products.
In 2023 my example was the call-to-action button: a label that is aligned and weighted well, padding inside, safe space around it, colour and sometimes a shadow. All of that is still true. But a button drawn well once is not a system, because the next screen draws it again, a little different.
That is the biggest change in how I work. In 2023 I treated composition as something you do on each screen. Now most of it lives in tokens and components. The button is one decision with all its states (default, hover, pressed, disabled), used everywhere, and the design work moves to the spaces between components: how they sit together, the order they stack in, and which one leads.
Rules are defaults
In 2023 the rules were the goal. Follow the grid, avoid serifs, use three colours. I wrote them as if they held everywhere.
Now I see them as defaults. A design system sets the default so most screens are right without anyone thinking about it. Then a designer can break one on purpose, when a screen needs something else to lead. A hero image can break the grid, a serif can carry a brand, and a chart can use more than three colours, as long as every pair passes its contrast ratio.
The title of this article is set in a serif, Playfair Display. In 2023 I told you to avoid serifs. On my site the serif is the one thing that marks writing as writing: big headlines only, never body text, never in a table. The rule still holds everywhere else, and I broke it in one place, on purpose.
What I try to avoid is breaking a rule by accident. When you break one on purpose, you know what was leading before and what leads now.